Alberta will maintain government’s current level of spending on physicians at $5.4 billion, and implement a new funding framework to avoid $2 billion in cost overruns by 2022-23.
The new physician funding framework will be introduced starting March 31, 2020. It's a multi-year process that will require consultation with the Alberta Medical Association (AMA) at all stages. It will include:
- implementing changes proposed during negotiations to prevent cost overruns
- aligning benefit programs and administrative fees with those of comparable provinces
- improving services for patients
Changes will also include government’s 11 Consultation Proposals based on appropriate patient care and use of insured services budget. The AMA, physicians, and other providers were consulted on these proposals. They were also brought to the AMA negotiations table.
New funding framework
Table 1: Practicing medicine under the old Alberta Medical Association Agreement vs. the new Physician Funding Framework.
AB Medical Association Agreement
Physician Funding Framework
|$5.4 billion in annual funding|
|Competitively paid physicians in Canada, including compensation for extra time with patients|
|As small business owners, choice and autonomy in how to practice, including hours of work and business model|
|Voluntary participation in a range of funding models (i.e., Alternative Relationship Plans)|
|A range of taxpayer funded benefit programs, including subsidized medical liability insurance and overhead costs, parental leave and compassionate care|
|Support for physicians in rural communities including recruitment, retention and training|
|Management of unsustainable taxpayer funded spending growth|
|Alignment of physician compensation with patient care|
- Government provided notice to the AMA that it intended to begin negotiations on the AMA Agreement. The notification provided time for the AMA to prepare its proposals.
- Negotiations began with the AMA to reach a new agreement and government began consultations on 11 proposed changes primarily related to the schedule of medical benefits (SOMB, or “insured services”).
- Negotiations and consultations proceeded with no agreement reached.
- Mediation, on both the negotiation and consultation proposals, began January 31 and continued into February.
- The parties were not able to reach an agreement during mediation.
- Government announced it will implement its final offer from the negotiating table, including the 11 consultation proposals, and some changes to benefit programs.
March 31, 2020
- The new Physician Funding Framework comes into effect starting March 31, 2020.
A new funding framework will address growing costs so government can address important frontline health care priorities like reducing surgical wait times, improving mental health and addiction services, and expanding the number of continuing care beds.
- The MacKinnon Report found that payments to Alberta physicians are significantly higher than comparable provinces like Ontario, BC and Quebec. It also found that more Alberta physicians are paid through a high cost fee-for-service model than other provinces.
- Alberta spends nearly 25% more per capita on physician services than comparable provinces.
- A doctor in Alberta earns roughly $90,000 more than a doctor in Ontario.
- Physicians’ fees have almost tripled since 2002. Without any changes, the current model would have cost taxpayers an additional $2 billion by 2022-23.
Spending growth on physicians is not sustainable and provides no better health results for Albertans.
Table 2: Average Gross Clinical Payment per Physician FTE (2017-18)
|Province||Gross Clinical Payment|
11 consultation proposals
The Government of Alberta made 11 consultation proposals to the AMA to enable Albertans to realize better health outcomes and build a stronger and more sustainable health system, while managing physicians spending growth. The 11 consultation proposals will not change how doctors practice medicine.
- Complex modifiers
On March 17, 2020, the Government of Alberta announced changes for complex modifiers will not go ahead as planned on March 31. Read the news release.
- Comprehensive annual care plans
This redundant billing code will be removed as physicians can bill for a comprehensive annual visit to provide patients advice on how to manage complex conditions.
- Driver medical exam for patients 74.5 or older
Having these drivers pay for their medical exam is consistent with other patients and will align with coverage in other provinces.
- Payments for diagnostic imaging referrals by uninsured practitioners
Only practitioners providing publicly funded services through the Alberta Health Care Insurance Plan will be able to refer for diagnostic imaging services, which is consistent with the approach taken by 4 other provinces. There is no change to the scope of practice of practitioners.
- Diagnostic image billing appropriateness
Streamlining physician fee codes for areas like diagnostic imaging will ensure services are billed the same way.
- Implement daily office volume caps
We are capping the number of daily patient visits to enable physicians to practice within reasonable patient loads.
Ensures physicians are not billing overhead costs such as equipment, supplies, leases and technical staff for work delivered in an AHS facility, as these costs are already covered by the public health facility.
- Clinical stipends provided by AHS
The practice of payment top-ups is a carry-over from when Alberta had several regional health authorities and is no longer appropriate as physicians are already compensated under the Alberta Health Care Insurance Plan.
- Submission of claims within 90 days
Giving practitioners 90 days to submit their payment claims, instead of 180, will improve budget forecasting, policy and planning decisions, an earlier publication of the Statistical Supplement and the inclusion of AHCIP benefits on the Statement of Benefits Paid – a product used by patients.
- Non-invasive diagnostic test fees in AHS facilities
Directing AHS to standardize the fees paid for non-invasive diagnostic procedures will ensure consistent compensation between hospital and non-hospital physicians.
- Stop accepting non-emergency good-faith claims
Ending the practice of submitting claims for services provided to patients who cannot provide proof of AHCIP coverage or Alberta residency will reduce the number of unpaid billing claims and ensure services are provided to eligible residents. Four other provinces do not provide good faith claims.
Benefit program changes
- Continuing Medical Education Program
Effective March 31, 2020, this program will be eliminated. This program currently reimburses eligible physicians for costs incurred for the maintenance and enhancement of knowledge, skills, and competency. This will bring Alberta in line with Ontario.
- Medical Liability Reimbursement Program
Effective March 31, 2020, funding for this program will be reduced. This program is administered by the Alberta Medical Association, and reimburses eligible physicians for costs incurred for medical liability insurance premiums set by the Canadian Medical Protection Association. Alberta is moving to a model with a fixed funding amount, which will move Alberta’s medical liability payment in the direction of peer comparators.
- Business Costs Program
Effective March 31, 2021, changes will be made to limit payments for the Business Costs Program(BCP) to the base rate for each visit. Physicians will no longer be able to claim BCP for modifiers paid in addition to the base rate.
- Rural Remote Northern Program
Effective March 31, 2021, eligibility criteria will be revised to ensure that only rural and remote communities are eligible for payments. Payments will change to a variable fee based on the isolation of a community. The program currently provides funding supports to urban communities (e.g. Spruce Grove).
Other compensation options
The Fee-For-Service model isn’t right for everyone. Clinical Alternative Relationship Plans (ARP) enable physicians to spend more time with patients and address complex needs, without worrying about their compensation being tied to delivering specific services.
Alberta Health is streamlining the process for creating an ARP:
- Once we receive an acceptable application, a Clinical ARP can be implemented within 6 weeks.
- The Expression of Interest and application forms will be updated to reduce the amount of information required. The updated forms concentrate on service delivery and how a Clinical ARP will improve patient care.
- A dedicated phone number and email has been set up to make it easier to inquire about Clinical ARPs
Why are you doing this?
Alberta’s physicians are essential partners and leaders in delivering our province’s health care system. The changes do not alter the key role that physicians play. The status quo is not sustainable and our ability to maintain high quality health care services now and into the future is in jeopardy.
- As per the terms of the agreement, Government provided notification that we wanted to negotiate in September 2019. Negotiations and consultations began in November 2019. After failing to reach an agreement through negotiations, voluntary mediation began on January 31, 2020.
- There were many meetings between the Minister, the AMA President and other members of both Alberta Health and the AMA. In addition, Minister attended the AMA Representative Forum in September 2019 and outlined the government’s fiscal position and need for change in front of 150 AMA leaders.
- Despite all of the official and unofficial discussions on this topic, the AMA proposal came nowhere close to managing growth in physician spending. Unfortunately, mediation talks ended after the same result.
- The existing model has not provided meaningful improvement to Alberta’s health outcomes. They still lag in serious ways, while spending increases each year. If things don’t change, then we are not going to achieve the breakthroughs we need on improving health outcomes for Albertans.
- We not only have a fiscal responsibility to deliver these changes, but we have a governance responsibility. We can no longer afford unreasonably high compensation for physicians that restrict us from being able to set and fund priorities across the health system.
What exactly is the new framework?
The new framework has 3 elements including:
- 11 changes, primarily to insured services, that concern physician compensation. The proposals are based on appropriate patient care, appropriate use of insured services budget, and alignment with other jurisdictions.
- Proposals tabled in negotiations with the AMA focused on reducing or eliminating benefit programs that exceed jurisdictional comparators.
- Savings identified through the Ernst and Young’s review of Alberta Health Services.
Are you cutting health spending?
No, the budget for physicians will remain at 2018-19 levels until 2022-23.
In Budget 2019, the government delivered on its commitment to maintain or increase the level of overall health spending, rather than making a hard cut. Health's operating budget is $20.6 billion in 2019-20, an increase of 1% from 2018-19. It will take all partners in the health system acting together to work within this overall budget.
This includes the government and physicians. Alberta will maintain government’s current level of spending on physicians at $5.4 billion.
What does this mean for doctors?
While there are some important structural changes in the new framework, the majority of physician programs, policies and benefits will remain unchanged. For example:
- Physicians will continue to be paid for their services.
- We will continue to compensate physicians for extra time spent with complex patients.
- Government supports for physician overhead costs, medical liability insurance, locums, rural incentives, and many other benefit programs will continue.
- Physicians and the AMA will continue to influence health care policy and delivery through participation in more than 60 AHS and Alberta Health committees.
- Physicians will continue to be paid at some of the highest rates in the country.
Is this really about improving patient care?
This is about putting in a new funding framework that’s been needed for a long time. One that drives the right dynamics and is respectful to doctors, affordable to taxpayers, and helps the system get better health results for Albertans.
This funding framework will control physician spending so unsustainable growth does not squeeze out spending on Albertans’ health priorities like reducing surgical wait-times or investing in continuing care.
Under this framework, Alberta physicians will still be among the highest paid in Canada.
Will doctors leave Alberta to go work in other provinces?
Alberta will remain an excellent place to practice medicine. We have:
- a long established primary care network that provides supports to family practitioners and their patients
- a single health authority
- an advanced IT infrastructure that allows physicians to share information
- an active partnership with the Rural Health Professions Action Plan to recruit and retain physicians in rural areas
- a generous benefits package that includes compassionate leave, parental leave, and medical liability
- two faculties of medicine
Can I still go to the doctor?
Yes, you can still go to the doctor, and your doctor will still be paid for your visit.
The new physician funding framework will not have an impact on physicians getting paid for their services. The Alberta Health Care Insurance Act requires the government to pay doctors for their services.
Albertans will still be able to visit their physicians, and physicians will continue to bill taxpayers.
Ask a question
If you don't find an answer in the questions above, complete the form below to ask a new question.
This information is collected so that we may provide you with updates.
The personal information is being collected and used pursuant to section 33(c) and section 39(1)(a) of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FOIP).
Questions regarding the collection, use, or disclosure of this information, may be directed to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Questions about the FOIP Act may be directed to the Information Access and Privacy office at 780-427-5848.
- New physician funding framework announced (February 20, 2020)
- Physician negotiations: Statement from Minister Shandro (Feb. 14, 2020)
- Mediator appointed for AMA negotiations: Joint statement (Jan. 31, 2020)
- Alberta Health Services Review: Minister Shandro (Aug. 8, 2019)
- Contractor selected to conduct AHS review (July 18, 2019)
- AHS Review to find savings, improve performance (May 30, 2019)